The Grounds of Ethical Judgement: New Transcendental Arguments in Moral Philosophy - Rilegato

Illies, Christian

Rilegato

ISBN 10: 0198238320 ISBN 13: 9780198238324

Casa editrice: Clarendon Press, 2003

Riassunto

Transcendental arguments have gained a lot of attention over the past twenty years, mainly in the field of theoretical reason. Yet few scholars have looked at their relevance to practical reason. Christian Illies argues that although this methodological avenue is not yet well-paved, transcendental arguments have great potential in ethics, as they promise rational justification of normative judgements.

There are two main types of transcendental argument that have been developed for this purpose in recent years. One is based on an analysis of the implications of agency (mainly by Alan Gewirth), the other on an analysis of reason as a discursive process with normative presuppositions (Karl-Otto Apel and other continental philosophers, but also Onora O'Neill). Illies finds that these arguments have severe limitations, and argues that practical reason should involve a different analysis: judgement formation must be analysed as a form of agency. Once this starting point is secured, by showing that it cannot rationally be denied, then two things can be transcendentally inferred: first, that there exists a categorical demand upon agents to arrive at true judgements, and second, that we must respect freedom of agency in general. Here our ordinary notions of right and wrong find secure ground.

Compelling and original, The Grounds of Ethical Judgement offers ample evidence that transcendental arguments may provide long-sought foundations for morality.

Su questo libro

Recensione:

His Illie's criticism of the typical methodologies of moral realists and of well-known, contemporary transcendental arguments are acutea useful addition to Kantian moral philosophy (The Review of Metaphysics)

Contenuti:

• Preface
• 1: Claims and Counter-claims: A General Introduction to Moral Realism
• 2: The Promise of Transcendental Arguments
• 3: The Argument from Discourse
• 4: The Argument from Agency
• 5: The Argument from Normative Consistency and the Goodnes of Truth and Freedom
• 6: Truth and Beyond
• References
• Index

Su questa edizione

• Editore: Clarendon Press
• Data di pubblicazione: 2003
• ISBN 10: 0198238320
• ISBN 13: 9780198238324
• Rilegatura: Copertina rigida
• Numero di pagine: 224