The Verdict of Battle: The Law of Victory and the Making of Modern War

Valutazione media 3,92
( su 13 valutazioni fornite da Goodreads )
 
9780674067141: The Verdict of Battle: The Law of Victory and the Making of Modern War

Today, war is considered a last resort for resolving disagreements. But a day of staged slaughter on the battlefield was once seen as a legitimate means of settling political disputes. James Whitman argues that pitched battle was essentially a trial with a lawful verdict. And when this contained form of battle ceased to exist, the law of victory gave way to the rule of unbridled force. The Verdict of Battle explains why the ritualized violence of the past was more effective than modern warfare in bringing carnage to an end, and why humanitarian laws that cling to a notion of war as evil have led to longer, more barbaric conflicts.

Belief that sovereigns could, by rights, wage war for profit made the eighteenth century battle’s golden age. A pitched battle was understood as a kind of legal proceeding in which both sides agreed to be bound by the result. To the victor went the spoils, including the fate of kingdoms. But with the nineteenth-century decline of monarchical legitimacy and the rise of republican sentiment, the public no longer accepted the verdict of pitched battles. Ideology rather than politics became war’s just cause. And because modern humanitarian law provided no means for declaring a victor or dispensing spoils at the end of battle, the violence of war dragged on.

The most dangerous wars, Whitman asserts in this iconoclastic tour de force, are the lawless wars we wage today to remake the world in the name of higher moral imperatives.

Le informazioni nella sezione "Riassunto" possono far riferimento a edizioni diverse di questo titolo.

About the Author:

James Q. Whitman is Ford Foundation Professor of Comparative and Foreign Law at Yale Law School.

Review:

Challenging contemporary views of the law of war and the function of battle, Whitman asks readers to forget what they know about post-Napoleonic wars of annihilation and revisit a time when a battle was a momentous wager to resolve disputes by "chance of arms." During the eighteenth century and well into the nineteenth, the side that held the field after a pitched battle could claim victory and so set the terms of peace. Battles were often bloody and vicious, but at least they produced definitive conclusions without spilling over into the rest of the country. Whitman knows it is pointless to wax nostalgic for a past form of warfare that might have worked for absolute monarchs but would hardly be suited to the modern world. Still, comparing earlier wars with contemporary "fights to the finish" allows him to ruminate about the possibilities for restraint in war and to challenge international lawyers to develop a "law of victory" that would support agreement on who had won a war and what was gained as a result. (Lawrence D. Freedman Foreign Affairs 2013-01-01)

Unlike some military historians, Whitman does not romanticize his subject, or express any nostalgia for what Oliver Wendell Holmes famously called the 'incommunicable experience' that allowed soldiers to feel 'the passion of life to its top.'...[The Verdict of Battle] offers a disturbing challenge to some of today's most widely held assumptions about the history of international relations... [Whitman displays] massive erudition, stiletto-sharp logic, and the heated, repetitive eloquence of a master litigator addressing a jury... A book that devotes so much time to Central European battles of the 1740s, and to legal luminaries whose careers pre-dated the American Revolution, will probably attract few readers in the Department of State or the United Nations. Yet the denizens of those institutions could do worse than to read this book and ponder its conclusions... Whitman has written an often brilliant book... An intelligent book such as The Verdict of Battle, which reaches back into history to provide a genuinely different perspective on warfare, deserves a serious hearing. (David A. Bell New Republic 2013-03-11)

Whitman offers a provocative argument against the idea that modern Western laws and practices of war represent a vast improvement over earlier models...The history Whitman provides is eye-opening. (Brian Bethune Maclean’s 2012-10-19)

At a time of growing insularity among American lawyers, [Whitman's] breadth of outlook is refreshing. He has a universal curiosity. His historical knowledge is impressive. He writes with elegance and wit...[A] stimulating book. (Jonathan Sumption Literary Review 2012-12-01)

This is one of the most remarkable books about law to have emerged in a long time. The depth and precision of the questions Whitman asks, and the originality of the answers he proposes, take us from the origins of the modern state to the ways in which law has determined many of the fundamental features of the modern world. Sure to be a classic, this stimulating and insightful book will appeal to any reader curious about war, battles, or how the world we inhabit came to be the way it is. (William Ewald, University of Pennsylvania Law School)

A truly wonderful work, written in a captivating style. The historical narrative is gripping, and impressive erudition springs from the pages. Whitman's bold argument is that by outlawing war, and any tangible winning, we have forced the entire exercise of war to exist outside of law, and therefore, outside any true limits. The Verdict of Battle is particularly challenging in its implications--what we can or cannot learn from this history--for conflict in the present day. (Gabriella Blum, author of Islands of Agreement: Managing Enduring Armed Rivalries)

The Verdict of Battle is an exceptionally important book from a master historian that places our current debates concerning the laws of war in a telling new light. Whitman is a provocative critic of the ways in which humanitarianism has come to modern law--and distorted our understanding of premodern warfare. The book will completely recast future discussion among historians and leave other readers pondering what can be done to legalize conflict to serve humanity for the better. (Samuel Moyn, author of The Last Utopia: Human Rights in History)

This book cannot be ignored. Impressively erudite and brilliantly audacious, it reinterprets centuries of writings on the law of war and offers fundamental revisions and refutations of modern authorities on the history of war itself. Readers will be challenged, and while they may dispute elements of Whitman's argument, they will gain immensely by coming to terms with his interpretations. The Verdict of Battle goes well beyond a "must-read"; it rises to the level of the essential. (John A. Lynn, author of Battle: A History of Combat and Culture)

In the course of unearthing the jus victoriae tradition, Whitman offers a badly needed and faintly blasphemous revision of the laws of war. (In contrast to the monoglot bibliographies of most Anglo-American scholarship on the laws of war, Whitman engages with original texts in both ancient and modern languages.) To begin with, Whitman scrapes off several decades’ worth of received ideas from just war theory, now enjoying a revival...Most refreshingly, Whitman rejects the piety that the laws of armed conflict--currently euphemistically called ‘international humanitarian law'--are crafted in order to restrain lethal violence, rather than to facilitate and optimize its use. Whitman cautions against the widespread faith in the power of law to beat swords into humanitarian surgical instruments...The legal tradition rediscovered by James Whitman may eventually be useful in world politics, as in the multipolar future that is very slowly arising. (Chase Madar Times Literary Supplement 2014-04-18)

Le informazioni nella sezione "Su questo libro" possono far riferimento a edizioni diverse di questo titolo.

I migliori risultati di ricerca su AbeBooks

1.

James Q. Whitman
Editore: HARVARD UNIVERSITY PRESS, United States (2012)
ISBN 10: 0674067142 ISBN 13: 9780674067141
Nuovi Rilegato Quantità: 1
Da
The Book Depository US
(London, Regno Unito)
Valutazione libreria
[?]

Descrizione libro HARVARD UNIVERSITY PRESS, United States, 2012. Hardback. Condizione libro: New. Language: English . Brand New Book. Today, war is considered a last resort for resolving disagreements. But a day of staged slaughter on the battlefield was once seen as a legitimate means of settling political disputes. James Whitman argues that pitched battle was essentially a trial with a lawful verdict. And when this contained form of battle ceased to exist, the law of victory gave way to the rule of unbridled force. The Verdict of Battle explains why the ritualized violence of the past was more effective than modern warfare in bringing carnage to an end, and why humanitarian laws that cling to a notion of war as evil have led to longer, more barbaric conflicts. Belief that sovereigns could, by rights, wage war for profit made the eighteenth century battle s golden age. A pitched battle was understood as a kind of legal proceeding in which both sides agreed to be bound by the result. To the victor went the spoils, including the fate of kingdoms. But with the nineteenth-century decline of monarchical legitimacy and the rise of republican sentiment, the public no longer accepted the verdict of pitched battles. Ideology rather than politics became war s just cause. And because modern humanitarian law provided no means for declaring a victor or dispensing spoils at the end of battle, the violence of war dragged on. The most dangerous wars, Whitman asserts in this iconoclastic tour de force, are the lawless wars we wage today to remake the world in the name of higher moral imperatives. Codice libro della libreria LIB9780674067141

Maggiori informazioni su questa libreria | Fare una domanda alla libreria

Compra nuovo
EUR 30,06
Convertire valuta

Aggiungere al carrello

Spese di spedizione: GRATIS
Da: Regno Unito a: U.S.A.
Destinazione, tempi e costi

2.

James Q. Whitman
Editore: Harvard University Press (2012)
ISBN 10: 0674067142 ISBN 13: 9780674067141
Nuovi Rilegato Quantità: 1
Da
Irish Booksellers
(Rumford, ME, U.S.A.)
Valutazione libreria
[?]

Descrizione libro Harvard University Press, 2012. Hardcover. Condizione libro: New. book. Codice libro della libreria 0674067142

Maggiori informazioni su questa libreria | Fare una domanda alla libreria

Compra nuovo
EUR 30,07
Convertire valuta

Aggiungere al carrello

Spese di spedizione: GRATIS
In U.S.A.
Destinazione, tempi e costi

3.

James Q. Whitman
Editore: Harvard University Press (2012)
ISBN 10: 0674067142 ISBN 13: 9780674067141
Nuovi Rilegato Quantità: 1
Da
Valutazione libreria
[?]

Descrizione libro Harvard University Press, 2012. Condizione libro: New. Codice libro della libreria L9780674067141

Maggiori informazioni su questa libreria | Fare una domanda alla libreria

Compra nuovo
EUR 28,07
Convertire valuta

Aggiungere al carrello

Spese di spedizione: EUR 3,99
Da: Germania a: U.S.A.
Destinazione, tempi e costi

4.

James Q. Whitman
Editore: HARVARD UNIVERSITY PRESS, United States (2012)
ISBN 10: 0674067142 ISBN 13: 9780674067141
Nuovi Rilegato Quantità: 1
Da
The Book Depository
(London, Regno Unito)
Valutazione libreria
[?]

Descrizione libro HARVARD UNIVERSITY PRESS, United States, 2012. Hardback. Condizione libro: New. Language: English . Brand New Book. Today, war is considered a last resort for resolving disagreements. But a day of staged slaughter on the battlefield was once seen as a legitimate means of settling political disputes. James Whitman argues that pitched battle was essentially a trial with a lawful verdict. And when this contained form of battle ceased to exist, the law of victory gave way to the rule of unbridled force. The Verdict of Battle explains why the ritualized violence of the past was more effective than modern warfare in bringing carnage to an end, and why humanitarian laws that cling to a notion of war as evil have led to longer, more barbaric conflicts. Belief that sovereigns could, by rights, wage war for profit made the eighteenth century battle s golden age. A pitched battle was understood as a kind of legal proceeding in which both sides agreed to be bound by the result. To the victor went the spoils, including the fate of kingdoms. But with the nineteenth-century decline of monarchical legitimacy and the rise of republican sentiment, the public no longer accepted the verdict of pitched battles. Ideology rather than politics became war s just cause. And because modern humanitarian law provided no means for declaring a victor or dispensing spoils at the end of battle, the violence of war dragged on. The most dangerous wars, Whitman asserts in this iconoclastic tour de force, are the lawless wars we wage today to remake the world in the name of higher moral imperatives. Codice libro della libreria LIB9780674067141

Maggiori informazioni su questa libreria | Fare una domanda alla libreria

Compra nuovo
EUR 33,89
Convertire valuta

Aggiungere al carrello

Spese di spedizione: GRATIS
Da: Regno Unito a: U.S.A.
Destinazione, tempi e costi

5.

James Q. Whitman
Editore: Harvard University Press Okt 2012 (2012)
ISBN 10: 0674067142 ISBN 13: 9780674067141
Nuovi Quantità: 1
Valutazione libreria
[?]

Descrizione libro Harvard University Press Okt 2012, 2012. Buch. Condizione libro: Neu. Neuware - Slaughter in battle was once seen as a legitimate way to settle disputes. When pitched battles ceased to exist, the law of victory gave way to the rule of unbridled force. Whitman explains why ritualized violence was more effective in ending carnage, and why humanitarian laws that view war as evil have led to longer, more barbaric conflicts. 323 pp. Englisch. Codice libro della libreria 9780674067141

Maggiori informazioni su questa libreria | Fare una domanda alla libreria

Compra nuovo
EUR 26,99
Convertire valuta

Aggiungere al carrello

Spese di spedizione: EUR 12,00
Da: Germania a: U.S.A.
Destinazione, tempi e costi

6.

Whitman, James Q.
Editore: Harvard Univ Pr (2012)
ISBN 10: 0674067142 ISBN 13: 9780674067141
Nuovi Rilegato Quantità: 1
Da
Revaluation Books
(Exeter, Regno Unito)
Valutazione libreria
[?]

Descrizione libro Harvard Univ Pr, 2012. Hardcover. Condizione libro: Brand New. sew edition. 323 pages. 9.50x6.25x1.25 inches. In Stock. Codice libro della libreria __0674067142

Maggiori informazioni su questa libreria | Fare una domanda alla libreria

Compra nuovo
EUR 33,13
Convertire valuta

Aggiungere al carrello

Spese di spedizione: EUR 6,71
Da: Regno Unito a: U.S.A.
Destinazione, tempi e costi

7.

Whitman, James Q.
Editore: Harvard University Press (2012)
ISBN 10: 0674067142 ISBN 13: 9780674067141
Nuovi Rilegato Quantità: 2
Da
Murray Media
(North Miami Beach, FL, U.S.A.)
Valutazione libreria
[?]

Descrizione libro Harvard University Press, 2012. Hardcover. Condizione libro: New. Codice libro della libreria P110674067142

Maggiori informazioni su questa libreria | Fare una domanda alla libreria

Compra nuovo
EUR 45,73
Convertire valuta

Aggiungere al carrello

Spese di spedizione: EUR 2,57
In U.S.A.
Destinazione, tempi e costi

8.

James Q. Whitman
Editore: Harvard University Press Okt 2012 (2012)
ISBN 10: 0674067142 ISBN 13: 9780674067141
Nuovi Quantità: 1
Da
AHA-BUCH GmbH
(Einbeck, Germania)
Valutazione libreria
[?]

Descrizione libro Harvard University Press Okt 2012, 2012. Buch. Condizione libro: Neu. Neuware - Slaughter in battle was once seen as a legitimate way to settle disputes. When pitched battles ceased to exist, the law of victory gave way to the rule of unbridled force. Whitman explains why ritualized violence was more effective in ending carnage, and why humanitarian laws that view war as evil have led to longer, more barbaric conflicts. 323 pp. Englisch. Codice libro della libreria 9780674067141

Maggiori informazioni su questa libreria | Fare una domanda alla libreria

Compra nuovo
EUR 26,99
Convertire valuta

Aggiungere al carrello

Spese di spedizione: EUR 29,50
Da: Germania a: U.S.A.
Destinazione, tempi e costi

9.

Whitman, James Q.
Editore: Harvard University Press
ISBN 10: 0674067142 ISBN 13: 9780674067141
Nuovi Rilegato Quantità: 1
Da
Cloud 9 Books
(Wellington, FL, U.S.A.)
Valutazione libreria
[?]

Descrizione libro Harvard University Press. Hardcover. Condizione libro: New. 0674067142 New Condition. Codice libro della libreria NEW6.0335218

Maggiori informazioni su questa libreria | Fare una domanda alla libreria

Compra nuovo
EUR 53,07
Convertire valuta

Aggiungere al carrello

Spese di spedizione: EUR 4,29
In U.S.A.
Destinazione, tempi e costi

10.

James Q. Whitman
Editore: Harvard University Press Okt 2012 (2012)
ISBN 10: 0674067142 ISBN 13: 9780674067141
Nuovi Quantità: 1
Da
buchversandmimpf2000
(Emtmannsberg, BAYE, Germania)
Valutazione libreria
[?]

Descrizione libro Harvard University Press Okt 2012, 2012. Buch. Condizione libro: Neu. Neuware - Slaughter in battle was once seen as a legitimate way to settle disputes. When pitched battles ceased to exist, the law of victory gave way to the rule of unbridled force. Whitman explains why ritualized violence was more effective in ending carnage, and why humanitarian laws that view war as evil have led to longer, more barbaric conflicts. 323 pp. Englisch. Codice libro della libreria 9780674067141

Maggiori informazioni su questa libreria | Fare una domanda alla libreria

Compra nuovo
EUR 26,99
Convertire valuta

Aggiungere al carrello

Spese di spedizione: EUR 35,00
Da: Germania a: U.S.A.
Destinazione, tempi e costi